--- title: "WoolSafe Research: The Effect of Enzyme-Containing Products on Wool Carpet" description: Consumers increasingly use enzymes or enzyme-producing bacteria in their formulations, which will lead to effective cleaning even with a reduced amount of surfactant and without strong additives. This is good for the environment, but is it safe for wool? Will the enzymes damage the wool in the carpet once they finished breaking down the protein in the staining? image: https://blog.aramsco.com/hubfs/Woolsafe%20Cover%20.jpg --- - [Home](https://aramsco.com) - [Pro's Corner](https://blog.aramsco.com) [![Aramsco](https://blog.aramsco.com/hubfs/Aramsco_May2019/Image/logo.png)](https://www.aramsco.com/) - [Home](https://aramsco.com) - [Pro's Corner](https://blog.aramsco.com) - Account - [locations](http://aramsco-live.epicorcommerce.com/locations/) - [education](http://aramsco-live.epicorcommerce.com/education/) - [about us](http://aramsco-live.epicorcommerce.com/aboutus/) # Pro's Corner ## [WoolSafe Research: The Effect of Enzyme-Containing Products on Wool Carpet](https://blog.aramsco.com/woolsafe-research-the-effect-of-enzyme-containing-products-on-wool-carpet) Posted by Tom Forsythe on Jun 15th 2022 As consumers’ demand for environmentally-friendly cleaning grows, chemical manufacturers strive to formulate greener, safer products. They increasingly use enzymes or enzyme-producing bacteria in their formulations, which will lead to effective cleaning even with a reduced amount of surfactant and without strong additives. This is good for the environment, but is it safe for wool? Will the enzymes damage the wool in the carpet once they finished breaking down the protein in the staining? WoolSafe had to investigate this. In the initial experiments, we used one product, a deodorizer, in different concentrations on a multi-colored 80% wool/20% nylon carpet. New and pre-worn carpet pieces were treated to see whether the damage was more likely on fibres already weakened by traffic. The deodorizer was sprayed on as recommended, making the carpet slightly damp. After thorough drying, the treatment was repeated three times to simulate multiple applications. We did not observe any change in the carpet’s appearance or handle even by the highest product application rate. None of the colours were affected either. The change of the pile height of all the differently treated samples was monitored whilst worn in the Hexapod machine, and we found no difference. Similarly, there was no difference between the amount of fibre shed by the differently treated samples during the test. Encouraged by these results, we widened the range of products and included a **urine treatment**, a **pre-spray** in the new experiments, and a **spotter** with the **deodorizer**, all from different manufacturers. This time we used the standard test carpet: 100% undyed, double-scoured wool. First, we made sure all the products that we used satisfied the standard WoolSafe criteria. Next, we treated the carpet samples with the maximum recommended dose six times, over a two-week period. After thorough drying and vacuuming, they were subjected to accelerated wear in the Hexapod machine, all together for 8000 revolutions, which represents 5 years of wear. After every 1000 revolutions the samples were vacuumed, the shed fibres collected, and the pile height measured.   ![Woolsafe Diagram 1](https://blog.aramsco.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Woolsafe%20Diagram%201.png?width=919&name=Woolsafe%20Diagram%201.png) Picture 1. Change of pile height during wear and after extraction with water.\* *\*Picture 1. shows that there is no significant difference between the decrease in pile height of the differently treated and the untreated sample. Moreover, when the samples later were extracted with warm water (in preparation for the alkaline solubility tests), all samples regained the lost height, confirming the lack of damage.*   Shedding during the experiment was minimal and similar for all treatments; if one of the enzyme-containing products had caused damage to the fibre, there would have been increased shedding. Another experiment often used to detect damage caused to wool fibres is the alkaline solubility test (ASTM D1283-05). The experiment involves dissolving a known amount of wool fibre in sodium hydroxide. Undamaged scoured wool has a typical alkali-solubility of 9 – 15%. Any deviation from that can indicate damage. First, we established the alkaline solubility of the wool from the untreated test carpet. The four samples gave an average solubility of 13.05% ±2.7%. The alkaline solubility of all samples is shown in *Table 1*. *![woolsafe diagram 2](https://blog.aramsco.com/hs-fs/hubfs/woolsafe%20diagram%202.jpg?width=597&name=woolsafe%20diagram%202.jpg)Table 1. Alkaline solubility test results* The last three figures are within tolerances, but the decreased solubility of the wool treated with the spotter and the urine treatment was slightly concerning. It could indicate that the treatment itself had already dissolved some of the fibre, decreasing the amount available to dissolve in the experiment. On the other hand, a high degree of damage would have opened more of the fibre, so solubility would have increased. To get a better picture of what was happening to the fibres, we sent multiple samples of each treated and not treated carpets so that they could be investigated with scanning electron microscopy. Only one of the samples treated with the spotter had some observable damage to the cortical cells; all other samples were the same as the untreated one and had no visible damage that could be attributed to the enzyme. If the enzyme had attacked the fibre, we would have observed increased shedding, poor wear characteristics, and damage to the fibres when investigated by scanning electron microscopy, but none of these occurred at a significant level. In these experiments, we used extreme circumstances, much higher than the recommended dosage over a long period of time without rinsing. We can reasonably assume that under normal usage none of these products would cause damage to wool carpets. As mentioned before, all of these products have satisfied the standard WoolSafe requirements. ## **Conclusion** ***We cannot see any reason for excluding products from WoolSafe testing simply because they contain enzymes. However, we still recommend thorough rinsing once finished.***   This article was originally written by Dr. Ágnes Zsednai and is published with their permission. [Rugs](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/rugs), [deodorization](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/deodorization) - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) [**BLOG HOME**](https://blog.aramsco.com/) **Where the professionals go to learn about:** - lead and asbestos abatement - professional cleaning - mold, fire, and water restoration - concrete surface preparation - business management ### Subscribe to Blog Search Search Google ### Recent Posts ### Posts by Topic - [Business (41)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/business) - [Aramsco Clean (37)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/aramsco-clean) - [Aramsco Restore (29)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/aramsco-restore) - [carpet cleaning (27)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/carpet-cleaning) - [Chemistry (19)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/chemistry) - [Aramsco Surface (14)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/aramsco-surface) - [Rugs (14)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/rugs) - [Carpet (12)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/carpet) - [target marketing (11)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/target-marketing) - [Concrete (10)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/concrete) - [Education (9)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/education) - [deodorization (9)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/deodorization) - [special agents (9)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/special-agents) - [upholstery cleaning (9)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/upholstery-cleaning) - [Carpet Presprays (8)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/carpet-presprays) - [Tile & Grout (8)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/tile-grout) - [customer service (8)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/customer-service) - [encapsulation (8)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/encapsulation) - [COVID-19 (7)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/covid-19) - [Spotting (7)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/spotting) - [Stain Removal (7)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/stain-removal) - [Surface Preparation (6)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/surface-preparation) - [Business Finance (5)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/business-finance) - [Customer communication and storytelling (5)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/customer-communication-and-storytelling) - [Grow your business (5)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/grow-your-business) - [carpet protector (5)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/carpet-protector) - [Equipment (4)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/equipment) - [Flooring (3)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/flooring) - [concrete surface preparation (3)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/concrete-surface-preparation) - [sales (3)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/sales) - [IICRC Classes (2)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/iicrc-classes) - [Restoration (2)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/restoration) - [Targeted Marketing (2)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/targeted-marketing) - [Trauma Cleaning (2)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/trauma-cleaning) - [Truckmount (2)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/truckmount) - [carpet coloring (2)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/carpet-coloring) - [Aramsco Service (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/aramsco-service) - [Customer Acquisition (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/customer-acquisition) - [fiber identification (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/fiber-identification) - [news releases (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/news-releases) - [portables (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/tag/portables) See all ### Blog Archive - [Tom Forsythe (130)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/tom-forsythe) - [Drew Crawford (50)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/drew-crawford) - [Aramsco Technical Staff (32)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/aramsco-technical-staff) - [Scott Warrington (18)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/scott-warrington) - [Jared Twitchell (15)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/jared-twitchell) - [Alex Morrill (12)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/alex-morrill) - [Steve Johnson (7)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/steve-johnson) - [Angela Buckendorf (5)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/angela-buckendorf) - [Rachel Adams (4)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/rachel-adams) - [Ron Colling (3)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/ron-colling) - [Seth Gifford (2)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/seth-gifford) - [Nancy Macdonald (2)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/nancy-macdonald) - [Gregg Sargent (2)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/gregg-sargent) - [Angela Buckendorf & Drew Crawford (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/angela-buckendorf-drew-crawford) - [Savaana Sihapanya (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/savaana-sihapanya) - [Dane Gregory (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/dane-gregory) - [Sandra Hummel (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/sandra-hummel) - [Luke Draeger (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/luke-draeger) - [Doyle Bloss (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/doyle-bloss) - [Tim Schaelling (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/tim-schaelling) - [Lucas Whitmer (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/lucas-whitmer) - [Schyler Lewis (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/schyler-lewis) - [Drew Crawford & Alex Morrill (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/drew-crawford-alex-morrill) - [Michelle Smith (1)](https://blog.aramsco.com/author/michelle-smith) See all #### Current Promotions Great deals on abatement, safety, surface preparation, and carpet cleaning equipment and chemicals! [Click to Save](https://aramsco.com/on-sale.html) #### Online Catalog All the restoration, safety, cleaning and surface preparation products you need in glossy, digital print. [See Products](https://cx.aramsco.com/?__hstc=88961988.ca7266f9997610aee14ebd89f4f37653.1557724048361.1557724048361.1557730574295.2&__hssc=88961988.1.1557730574295&__hsfp=35742670) #### Nexus Conference Updates on the industry's top conference. Demos, Education, Networking, and Fun! [Learn More](https://nexus.aramsco.com/?__hstc=88961988.ca7266f9997610aee14ebd89f4f37653.1557724048361.1557724048361.1557730574295.2&__hssc=88961988.1.1557730574295&__hsfp=35742670) - Shop By Categories - [Air Scrubbers](https://www.aramsco.com/equipment-instruments/negative-air-air-scrubbers.html) - [Carpet Cleaning Chemicals](https://www.aramsco.com/chemicals/cleaning.html) - [Cleaning Equipment](https://www.aramsco.com/equipment-instruments/cleaning-equipment.html) - [Cleaning Tools](https://www.aramsco.com/tools-supplies/cleaning-tools-supplies.html) - [Concrete Grinding](https://aramsco.com/equipment-instruments/grinders-polishers.html) - [Disinfectants & Antimicrobials](https://www.aramsco.com/chemicals/disinfectants-antimicrobials.html) - [Drying Equipment](https://www.aramsco.com/equipment-instruments/drying.html) - [Floor Scrapers](https://www.aramsco.com/equipment-instruments/scrapers.html) - [Mastic Removers](https://www.aramsco.com/chemicals/adhesive-coating-removers.html) - [Odor Neutralizers](https://www.aramsco.com/chemicals/odor-control.html) - [Poly Sheeting](https://www.aramsco.com/plastics-adhesives/poly-sheeting.html) - [Respirators](https://www.aramsco.com/safety-ppe/respirators-respiratory-protection.html) - [Shot Blasting](https://www.aramsco.com/equipment-instruments/shot-abrasive-blasting.html) - [Thermal Imaging](https://www.aramsco.com/equipment-instruments/meters-testing/infrared-temperature.html) - [Vacuums](https://www.aramsco.com/equipment-instruments/vacuums.html) - Resources - [Pro's Corner](https://blog.aramsco.com) - [Classifieds](https://classifieds.aramsco.com/) - [Monthly Ad](https://cx.aramsco.com/) - [Education Schedule](https://www.cvent.com/c/calendar/ab53c6cb-fee0-44a6-a384-c51a2a4b32c0) - [Equipment Financing](https://aztecfinancial.com/) - [Equipment Rental](https://www.aramsco.com/training-rentals-repairs) - [Equipment Repair](https://www.aramsco.com/training-rentals-repairs) - [Site Map](https://www.aramsco.com/training-rentals-repairs) - Company Info - [About Us](https://www.aramsco.com/aboutus) - [Careers](https://workforcenow.adp.com/jobs/apply/posting.html?client=aramsco&ccId=19000101_000001&type=MP&lang=en_US) - [Contact Us](https://www.aramsco.com/contact) - [News](https://www.aramsco.com/news) - OUR BRANDS - [Aztec Financial](https://aztecfinancial.com/) - [NSS](https://nssusa.com/) - [Safety Express](http://safetyexpress.com/?__hstc=88961988.ca7266f9997610aee14ebd89f4f37653.1557724048361.1557724048361.1557730574295.2&__hssc=88961988.2.1557730574295&__hsfp=35742670) - Policies - [Privacy Policy](https://www.aramsco.com/privacy-policy) - [Return Policy](https://www.aramsco.com/terms-conditions#returns) - [Shipping Policy](https://www.aramsco.com/terms-conditions#shipping) - [Terms & Conditions](https://www.aramsco.com/terms-conditions) - Corporate Location - Find a location Near You - [Location image](https://www.aramsco.com/locations) Corporate Location - Aramsco, Inc. Five Radnor Corporate Center 100 Matsonford Road Suite 510 Radnor, PA 19087  - (800) 767-6933 - customer.service@aramsco.com Copyright © 2025 Aramsco. All rights reserved. ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Tom Forsythe", "url" : "https://blog.aramsco.com/author/tom-forsythe" }, "dateModified" : "2022-06-15T22:29:22.695Z", "datePublished" : "2022-06-15T22:29:22.000Z", "headline" : "WoolSafe Research: The Effect of Enzyme-Containing Products on Wool Carpet", "image" : [ "https://blog.aramsco.com/hubfs/Woolsafe%20Cover%20.jpg" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://blog.aramsco.com/woolsafe-research-the-effect-of-enzyme-containing-products-on-wool-carpet", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://blog.aramsco.com/hubfs/Logos/Aramsco%20R%20Family%20-%20Equipped%20for%20Success.png" }, "name" : "Aramsco" } } ```